Abercrombie & Fitch (NYSE:ANF) might have just executed one of the trendier turnarounds in recent retail history. Shares of the company jumped more than 30% on Wednesday after it posted better-than-expected first-quarter results and upped its full-year sales forecast range.

Vintage T-shirts and printed jeans may be hot with Gen Z, but Abercrombie’s bottom line was the real seasonal surprise.

Yet, despite the eye-catching move in the stock, the impact on retail-focused ETFs was less runway-ready.

The SPDR S&P Retail ETF (NYSE:XRT), ProShares Online Retail ETF (NYSE:ONLN), and Amplify Online Retail ETF (NYSE:IBUY) barely flinched in the aftermath of Abercrombie's earnings beat. The reason is simple: Abercrombie & Fitch doesn't carry enough weight in these ETFs to move the needle.

It’s a textbook instance of a top solo performer in a large lineup. Abercrombie is performing well, but retail ETFs are typically diversified among dozens of names, several of which aren’t exhibiting the same level of momentum.

Small-Cap Funds Could Be The True Winners

Investors in search of ETF vehicles that truly experienced the glow of Abercrombie’s breakout may wish to look at the small-cap category. Vehicles such as the iShares Core S&P Small-Cap ETF (NYSE:IJR) and the Vanguard Small-Cap Value ETF (NYSE:VBR) provide comparatively higher exposure to the apparel retailer.

Abercrombie is a top-10 holding in IJR, and its outsized move can give a modest lift to fund performance, though still dampened by the broader small-cap environment. VBR also holds Abercrobmie, indicating the company’s reclassification as a value stock amid strengthening fundamentals.

What Abercrombie’s Numbers Mean For The Sector

The firm reported first-quarter net sales of $1.10 billion, surpassing forecasts of $1.07 billion. Comparable sales for its Hollister brand jumped 23% — a testament that recent product refreshes are resonating among teens and pre-teens. However, it also reduced full-year profit guidance due to continuing tariff pressures.

Abercrombie’s refusal to abandon its store growth strategy and increase marketing for the summer quarter implies that management thinks the brand is still trending, despite macroeconomic conditions remaining patchy.

Shoppers are still willing to pay for brands that are getting the product-market fit right.

Abercrombie’s rally might not have put a shockwave into broad retail ETFs, but it’s a reminder that stock-specific victories in the apparel sector can be harbingers of larger style changes, both in consumer activity and in ETF exposure tactics.

Abercrombie’s profits remind us that apparel retail is not a homogeneous investment category. Though the brand’s rebound has minimal impact on most mainstream ETFs, it can be enriching quietly in small-cap and value funds.

For ETF investors, the takeaway might be: fashion trends happen overnight, but being fashionable with your portfolio means taking a closer peek at what’s inside the fund.

Read Next:

• KRE Falls Behind XLF, Sparks SVB Collapse Flashbacks: Are ETFs Sensing Bank Trouble?

Photo: Shutterstock